The shortcomings of the electoral college system
The electoral college helps keep the two-party system strong it makes it very hard for a third party to break through at the national level and increases the risk that a third party could spoil a candidate’s chance of winning, which in turn discourages people from voting for third-party candidates. The primary advantage of the electoral college is its ability to simplify elections its primary disadvantage is inequalities among different states despite its waning popularity, states are unlikely to ever support a constitutional amendment abolishing the electoral college. The electoral college encourages a two-party system and rewards candidates who have broad appeal a direct popular election would make it more possible for third-party candidates to succeed and would also encourage political parties to become more radical and extreme. My main problem with the electoral college is that it’s no longer allowed to do its intended job if you read federalist 68 by alexander hamilton, he details the type of candidate that could win over enough voters to ascend to the highest office in the land if there is nothing in place to temper the will of the people.
The advantages and disadvantages of the electoral college show us that the system, while imperfect in some ways, has been a beneficial force in the elections held in the united states since its founding. The most usual proposal for reform is to simply do away with the electoral college and have a direct vote by the people this has advantages and disadvantages, of course. The electoral college system was originally set up by the founding fathers in order to retain a representative form of government, establishing it within the constitution as the compromise between the election of the president based on the common vote of eligible citizens and the election of the president by the vote within congress. The electoral college is a state-by-state winner-take-all system, which ensures that any dispute in the counting would be an isolated case in particular states 5 it gives all candidates a chance for considerable success.
The electoral college was set up to show a clear winner in us presidential elections however, it is possible a candidate can win the popular vote yet lose the electoral college vote, therefore. Trump's right, the electoral college is a 'disaster for democracy,' and we can change it after the second election in 16 years in which the winner of the national popular vote will be denied the. The electoral college is often considered to be an outdated system of popular voting it requires a state population to select electors to vote for them for a candidate electors represent part. Under the electoral college system, however, they have the least incentive or need to cheat for their presidential candidate using a direct election system, dishonest officials in one-party. The pros and cons of the electoral college show us a system that was implemented to create more of a level playing field as the us has evolved, however, some feel that the time to take another look at this election system has come.
The biggest advantage of the electoral college system was that it allowed different states to have different requirements for voting in practice, this allowed the following changes to happen gradually. The american system, using the electoral college, is out-dated and was probably a bad idea to begin with most people don't understand it and it has caused many problems in the past. The electoral college was established by article ii, section i of the constitution while the constitution originally stated that electors would cast votes for two candidates, with the first. A) what are the pros and cons of the electoral college an interesting point to this discussion is that many of the “pros” are argued by some to be disadvantages, and many of the “cons” are believed to be the advantages of the system by others.
The shortcomings of the electoral college system
In order to determine the main advantages and disadvantages of both majoritarian and proportional government within electoral systems it is vital that we discuss the founding principles of each and how each version within both (eg, majoritarian- first past the post, alternative vote and second ballot system and proportional-single transferable. Get an answer for 'analyze criticism of the electoral college system and the alleged advantages and disadvantages of various reform proposals' and find homework help for other history questions. The electoral college was established in 1788 by article ii of the us constitution, which also established the executive branch of the us government, and was revised by the twelfth amendment (ratified june 15, 1804), the fourteenth amendment (ratified july 1868), and the twenty-third amendment (ratified mar 29, 1961. Numerous movements have aimed to go from an electoral college to a popular election, but the system remains here are some of the pros and cons of the electoral college pros.
- The electoral college is a body of delegates which represent each state within the united states they are selected to provide votes on behalf of how their state population voted in a presidential election.
- The electoral college system after the last presidential election, which is still underway apparently, there is much controversy over what should happen to the electoral college system there are people who say that the electoral college is good but should be modified to meet the needs of the modern world.
- The electoral college: pro: the founders of this nation had a justified fear of complete democracy they set up a system where supposedly wise men, elected by the people, and holding no other office at the time, would chose a president.
The electoral college is one of the most significant political systems ever created in the united states, this system determines who will become the president, and runs on a winner-take-all system for the reasons of it creating complications in the election process, it decreasing the chance of a third party existing, and lowering public. In the presidential election of 2000, the electoral college system resulted in a president and vice president who received more electoral votes, but fewer popular votes, than the electoral vote runners-up for the first time in 112 years, a classic case of what some observers identify as an electoral college misfire. 12) the electoral college system -- and even more, the provision of the twelfth amendment that throws an election without an electoral college majority to the house of representatives -- makes it far easier to steal an election.